Sunday, August 31, 2008

Notes from Our Tuesday Meeting

On Tuesday, August 26th, we met with Dave Hermann, the Consultant hired by the Conference. Afterwards, the Long Range Planning Committee met to discuss things. Here are my notes. Sorry if they're a little late.....

Meeting w/Dave Hermann

Dave discussed the report that he prepared for us based upon the ministry survey we submitted. (Both are available, just check with Ingrid at the Church Office. Also available is a video of the meetin wih Dave.) He labeled this report as a "snapshot"; Our goal is to achieve a "compass reading." Overall, Dave was complementary of our Church and of our effort to confront some of the big issues that lay before us.

According to Dave, it appears our Church has been in tension regarding how big we should be. This is something, we probably haven't openly discussed and certainly haven't decided with clarity. Historically, we start to grow, reach a certain point, and then shrink to our historical size.

As a church, we are on the cusp between a


  • Pastoral sized church -- 50-150 average attendance -- relationship based, lots of warmth, etc. and a
  • Program sized church -- 150+ members -- teams, new feel, etc.
We have to decide which model we want to follow. This decision carries risk. The transformation from being Pastor driven to being Program driven is the hardest shift for a church to make. For this transformantion to work, we must create a feeling of intimacy so that we maintain the warmth and family feel that so many of our members cherish.

Another interesting fact: 75% of our active membership lives within 3 miles of the Church. If the Church is going to grow we have to get beyond the three mile marker", i.e., we have to become more regional in nature.

Church growth, especially changing models from being Pastoral to Progam can cause an upheaval. As Bishop Huie says, "Transformation is messy." Doing this right, will take three things...


  • Top Quality Programs
  • Small Groups -- we can't have too many.
  • Intensive Evangelism.

One thing Dave mentioned is the concept of a capital campaign for a ministry rather than a building.

When asked about targeting growth, i.e., should we throw out a wide net and try to bring in everyone or should we target particular groups?, Dave believed we should target in an understanding way, that is we should select groups and target them with excellence. (This is not to say we should be exclutionary towards anyone, simply that we can't be everything to everyone, so what we decide to do, we should do well.)

There is a difference between discernment and decisions...

Discernment -- What is God's will?
Decision -- What do I think is right?

We need to be discerning, not deciding.

We need to grow disciples and encourage people to pray.

Small groups are essential: We need to grow bigger by getting smaller.

Committee Meeting Notes --- Immediately following Dave's Presentation

We opened with a devotional based upon 1 Samuel 3:11 and discussed what makes us all "tingle" with excitement. Things that make us tingle are

  • Enthusiasm
  • Encouragement, Upbeat people
  • The future
  • Music
  • Sharing your vision
  • Patriotism
  • Sincerity
  • Children

We then discussed what makes us nervous. In general, we are nervous about

  • Change and growth
  • People's reactions
  • Not leaving anyone behind.

What did we learn from Dave? To be dynamic and successfully grow we must build intimacy through small groups.

Our plan is to have another Town Hall meeting like we had several weeks ago. This one would be after the 10:30 service, coupled with a Disciple Diner, if possible. We focused on Sepember 7th (but as you can see from another post to this blog, there is no DD scheduled for that day. This is something we need to resolve.)

That's it, comments, corrections and feedback always welcomed.

Saturday, August 30, 2008

A Good Perspective

"When your memories exceed your dreams, you're headed for the grave"

Jim Horsley -- former Blue Angel and highly decorated Navy Fighter Pilot and author of "A Different Kind of Courage."

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Next Town Hall Meeting

At our meeting Tuesday night -- which I still owe you notes for -- we decided to hold another town hall after the 10:30 service on Sept 7th, in conjunction with the Disciple Diner.

Only one problem -- no disciple diner this month.

Anyone got an idea on what we should do?

Please discuss this by entering your reply below.

(To do this you can post anonymously, i.e., without registering -- if you do this please put your name in the post, or you can register. Either way is simple.)

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Transforming Ministry Workshop w/Dave Herman

All... This afternoon, Deborah and I attended a transforming ministry workshop at Sunset UMC in Pasadena. Dave Herman, our transformation consultant talked for a couple of hours -- first on structure and then on ministering to young adults.


Dave Herman is a dynamic speaker. The time flew by and I could have easily listened for two hours more. It was fabulous.


Here are some highlights from my notes, which don't do justice to the talk...

Gary


Leadership

The first thing to think about when talking about Leadership is structure:

1. All Churches have structure.
2. These structures affect ministry.
3. They affect growth and everything else.


Over time your strucure can become outdated and inhibit the Church rather than enable it.

Leadership is an essential element to making structure work:

Structure w/o good leadership:

- oppressive
- confining
- defensive

Structure w/good leadership:
- empowering
-creative
- energizing

Leaders use structures to build healthy systems.
1. If you want healthy structures, focus on the leaders who build them.
2. Structures don't build leaders, leaders build structures.

"It takes teamwork to make the dream work."

Without leadership, the structure becomes the leader.
you get chaos without creativity.

  • you default to rules and procedures.
  • a team w/o a leader will argue for hours about procedure and miss ministry opportunities.
  • teams lose sight of why they're there.

Leadership...
  • seeks freeing vision
  • seels spiritual liberation
  • takes risks and builds structure that can change
The Church's two arms of Leadership -- both are essential.

  • Pastors -- equip, strengthen and deploy.
  • Laity -- do the ministry.
The laity is the most significant resource in the Church. More than the building, more than the bank account, more than anything. They should not rely on the pastor to do their job!

A Skipped Generation -- Young Adults
And the LORD said to Samuel: "See, I am about to do something in Israel that will make the ears of everyone who hears of it tingle" 1 Samuel 3:11 (NIV)

To reach young adults, we need to discover a message for young adults that will make their ears tingle.

Does your heart THIRST for the chance to minister to younger adults? (This is not a rhetorical question!). This can be risky:

If you have nothing to offer them, you have nothing to say to them! What is in it for them? Do you really want to reach out to them or do you just want to feel good about yourself by having them around.... You checked a box in another demographic?

Why young adult ministries stall:

  • You haven't listened to their hearts.
  • You've resisted the urge to be too different, too free.
  • You don't realize that modified control is still control -- and what you control, you stifle.

Since the 1950's the Church has been run by two generations: the Boomers and the Survivors. These generations generally assume that young adults want what has been built for them. This assumption isn't generally true.

Young adult ministry is about building community. It's people helping people. (Mission projects are often more appealing than attending worship services.)

Young adults want to connect with each other. "Hanging out" is not just entertainment, it is self-discovery in the context of friends.

The "Skipped Generation" wants:

  • Church where lives are changed and people share their witness and celebrate.
  • Faith-based Church that stands for something. These people have a deep social conscience and they want a church that helps them act on it.
  • A place to serve and share their gifts and talents with their friends. They will buy into a servant evangelism.
  • Lasting relationships

They are waiting for the Church to join them!

Monday, August 18, 2008

August 10th Town Hall Results

On Sunday, August 10th, we had our first town hall meeting. The approximately 50 attendees were divided into tables and each table was asked to prayerfully consider the following question...





What is God calling St. John’s to be in our community?



Here's what the different groups had to say...
GROUP 1:

Children/?, educational
To grow/want to see growth
Involvement – go out seeking
Inviting guest
Hours too early
Possibly switch service
But contemporary service, earlier convenient
Saturday functions, publicity, attract young families – FREE
Door hangers (apartments)
Flyers, advertisement
Non denominations – taking names off of the church
Young couple Sunday school – growth of Sunday school classes and
contemporary service
Teaching sources for the children and young people ex: music,
fun tactics
Vacation Bible school, fun, hands-on, learning with fun
Not inviting, more comfortable feel, energy
Church work day to make it more inviting
Kid’s wall (hand prints) within church

GROUP 2:

To love each other. To show love to everyone even though we
may not want to
Witness – reach out
To show others we are here.
Are we doing this backwards –
i.e. - Why are people leaving (all churches) People get
their feelings hurt?
People visit – become members – and leave (get them involved)
Do we want to grow?
Draw people with youth
Advertise/promotional/provide needs of community –
i.e. - LARGE health fair
Draw youth – Back to School Bash
Meet community needs first – to draw them into worship –
i.e. – provide school supplies



GROUP 3:

Need to be more missions driven, community outreach – get more
people involved especially younger; older ones are getting tired
Thanksgiving dinner good community outreach, but it’s not just
St. John’s – need something to get our name known in community
Start back up Mother’s Day Out
After school programs as a community service – latch key, KFC,
Keys, Leap, tutor program, etc.
Need to be more diverse – add Spanish speaking service; visit
other churches to get ideas (like was done for contemporary)
Praise activities for community
Attract youth – “rock” band and praise – evening worship service
Attract young families
Much is good - expand on that without losing anything
Build on VBS
Everyone bring one
Young couples groups, activities, Sunday school
Flyers, block party – not seem to reach community

GROUP 4:

Merger was missed opportunity
Traditional churches are struggling due to type of service –
more praise services
Comfortable in jeans at contemporary
Music style influences attendance – youth especially
Youth needs more involvement – finances are struggles for
youth program, youth help draw community to church
Solid Christian foundation
Individuals need fulfillment in worship experience
Passionate minister determined to growth and outreach –
“build a fire underneath church”
Church needs purpose past its walls
Church can draw community with open doors during week –
particularly nights; family activities
Sunday morning “first experience” is most important
Members are seeing the “greeting” atmosphere slipping
Missing “family” since new service – need to grow both services


GROUP 5:

Unchurched – find them
More from early service – 10:30 is just going through the motions
- need to change
Worry about who will replace Chris P.
Put 2 choirs together to sing.
Children (youth teens) are going to non-denominational churches
Music revives you
Important for older to support what younger want because older
people will be gone
Moving is not the answer
Maybe call people who visit
Combine with other Methodist churches
Combine for a Sunday night service
Hunt new families who do not go to church
Ad in Post (local)
Concert with praise band – college
Trunk or Treat – praise band
Publicity for St.Johns
College ministry – 17@party
Need more advertisement
KSBJ – Advertise Free
Mainland Ministries – get St.Johns name on that
Community chapel -
Take advantage of Deborah




GROUP 6:

It was noted that many of our members just come in “get it and go” like McDonalds. Many don’t hang around after church to participate in disciple dinners, picnics, etc. There are a few doing all the work as a result-same folks, some of whom are getting tired. One or two felt that the two separate services hurt the church. Michael Myers said that First Methodist is working with blending the morning service with traditional and praise type music and it seems to be working well according to Michael. Long term answer was to combine the three Methodist churches in town now, as several said it made no sense to have so many in one town.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Third Meeting -- Planning for Congregational Outreach

The planning committee met on July 14th to discuss how we can best reach the congregation. Here's what we came up with:

  • We will have a Congregational Town Hall on Sunday, August 10th.
    The Town Hall will be held between the first and second services during the Sunday School hour.
    Breakfast will be served
    We will ask the attendees to meet in the Family Life Center.
    People will be asked to break up into tables.
    Gary will moderate per the agenda below.
    Members of the Committee will join the tables and facilitate the discussions.
    Notes from each table will be collected.
    The Committee will meet soon afterwards and compile our notes.


Agenda for the Town Hall


  • Opening Prayer
    Informaton on the planning process and what why we're together today.
    At each table:
    Solicit answers to the first question: Who are we?
    Solicit answers to the second question: What has God called us to do?
    Solicit answers to the third question: Who is our neighbor?
    Wrap Up
    Closing Prayer.

Please continue to pray for the Committee and the Church to help us discern God's mission for us.

Sunday, July 13, 2008

Collecting Information

It's now mid-July and here's where we are:



The ministry survey is a collection of all sorts of information about our Church and our community. It has been completed and submitted to our consultant Dave Herman. The survey itself provides some very good insight to our Church and our community. If anyone is interested in the survey it is available fromt the Church office.



I've been a little remiss in not keeping this up, so here's the skinny on the first meeting of the committee last April: Not a whole lot happened. We got acquainted and were set on the mission of talking to people and doing some reading. The imporant think is that we all agreed that this effort has to take place in the open -- in other words: NO SECRETS!



We had our second meeting of the Long Range Planning Committee on Monday, June 30. Following are some notes from that meeting.



Long Range Planning Committee
Notes from our June 30th Meeting
Attendees: Gary Scoggin, Kay Ashworth, Peggy Jakubik, Debbie Krebs, Lawrence Wheatley, David Hyde, Deborah Proctor.


Devotional: Acts 1:4-9
4On one occasion, while he was eating with them, he gave them this command: "Do not leave Jerusalem, but wait for the gift my Father promised, which you have heard me speak about. 5For John baptized with water, but in a few days you will be baptized with the Holy Spirit." 6So when they met together, they asked him, "Lord, are you at this time going to restore the kingdom to Israel?" 7He said to them: "It is not for you to know the times or dates the Father has set by his own authority. 8But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes on you; and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the ends of the earth." 9After he said this, he was taken up before their very eyes, and a cloud hid him from their sight.

What we found surprising about the Ministry Survey:

The educational level of the congregation is higher than we expected.
We have a high number of people who tithe 10% or more of their incomes.
The income level of the congregation is higher than we expected.
The low level of spending we have on leadership development.
More people live closer to the Church than we thought.
Our location may actually be an advantage.
The population in our zip code is younger than what we thought. (38% is school aged or younger.)

Strengths-Weaknesses-Opportunity-Threats:



Strengths
Friendliness
Financial Capacity
Family atmosphere, close knit.
Members live close by
Good physical facilities
Youth Group
Music Program

Two choices in Worship



Weaknesses
Sunday School Program
Children’s ministry lacking
We are still feeling the effects of families who have left.
“Irregular” church attendees.
Lack of racial diversity.

Location, not visible.



Opportunities
Local neighborhood-based ministries.
There are a lot of children in town.
Reinstate presence in programs like Mother’s Day Out and after school.

Four United Methodist Churches in town that could work together.



Threats
Apathy, inertia.
Pull of the non-denominational churches away from us.
Lots of two income families make it difficult for people to get involved.
Competition from sports, extra-curricular activities, etc. for Youth’s attention (especially on Sundays.)
Hard to kept things going – the Church has little staff and things are volunteer-driven.

Two services get the congregation disconnected.



What did we just learn?
We need to keep looking at the big picture.
There are lots of strengths, opportunities to work from.
Don’t let some areas get too much attention while others deteriorate.

Next Steps
We will hold Structured Conversations with the Congregation.
These conversations should engage as many people as possible.
They should be “God-centered”, i.e., “What is God calling us to do?”, “Where do we see God at work around us?”
We will meet to work on this: Monday, July 14 – 7:00 am at the Parlor.
Gary will put together some stuff to work from at the meeting.

Committee members need to come to this meeting prepared to take away assignments for the Congregational conversation!

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Getting Kicked Off

It's late April and we're finally getting kicked off!

We have an approved committee, the members of which are listed at right.

Our first meeting is this coming Sunday (April 27th, right after Church.)

We've alteady started compiling information for the Transformation Survey. This survey, designed by the Conference transformation consultant, is a tool to collect the data needed to assess our situation and begin plotting our future. ( I was planning to design such a tool myself but when this one arrived, I realized it was exactly what we needed!) People from committees all over the church are assisting in collecting data.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Presentation at the Ad Council Retreat

We kicked off our Long Range planning efforts today at the St. John's annual Administrative Council retreat.

After a presentation about what this effort was about, we went to the task of forming the team to do the work.

Using a technique suggested in the book Holy Conversations, we asked the Council members for a list of ideas of the traits we would find in people we would want on a planning committee and a list of the traits we would not want to find in these people.

The traits we would want included..
  • Charter member,
  • open minded,
  • take change,
  • steady,
  • detail oriented,
  • creative ideas, visionary,
  • respected by the congregation.,
  • recognized as “worker bee” – follow thru,
  • loves the church, wants the best for church,
  • positive minded,
  • cross section of congr. (age, length of membership, male/female, etc),
  • see the need for long range plan,
  • embraces the need for change,
  • time and willingness to do the job,
  • understand God is in charge - more about what God wants, not what we want – seeks God’s will,
  • someone who inspires others.

The traits we wouldn't want to see included...

  • Eeyores (negative, pessimistic)
  • No enthusiasm
  • “It won’t work”
  • Resistant to change
  • Exactly the same as current leadership
  • Rigid, inflexibleBullies
  • Won’t see it through to end
  • Won’t speak their truth – come out not really “bought into” ideas
Using these list as a guide, Ad Council members were asked to come up with a few names of people who fit these criteria.


We'll take this collective list and develop a proposed membership for the planning committee.